Sutton 58

426 East 58th Street | Sutton Place | built 1910

Open on the map10 entries

The lot about 1940
About 1940. Via 1940s.nyc
The lot about 1985
About 1985. Via 80s.nyc

The city photographed every building for its tax records around 1940 and again in the 1980s. NYC Municipal Archives.

Written with AI from the source each entry cites, then fact-checked.

  1. 2015

    January

    The Bauhouse Group begins assembling low-rise buildings on East 58th Street for a luxury tower

    The Bauhouse Group took control of three neighboring low-rise buildings on East 58th Street in January 2015, and in March it added a fourth with 100,000 square feet of air rights. That August it paid $37.9 million for a further 109,000 square feet of air rights. The firm planned a Foster and Partners tower about 1,000 feet tall.

    Source: Wikipedia

  2. 2015

    July

    Neighbors learn the planned Sutton Place tower will rise 90 stories, not 30

    The Bauhouse Group had been assembling adjoining East 58th Street lots since January 2015 for a condominium tower by Foster and Partners. Residents of neighboring 434 East 58th Street, who had sold their air rights for $11 million after hearing the building would run 13 to 30 stories, learned in July that the plan called for about 90 stories and roughly 1,000 feet. A Bauhouse spokesperson said the building had grown in size as the site assembly continued.

    Source: Wikipedia

  3. 2016

    February

    Bauhouse files for bankruptcy two days before a foreclosure auction of the site

    Bauhouse defaulted in January 2016 on a $147 million loan from Gamma Real Estate, and Gamma began foreclosure early the next month. A judge refused on February 23 to stop it. Bauhouse then filed for bankruptcy on the site two days before the scheduled February 29 auction, which cancelled the sale.

    Source: Wikipedia

  4. 2016

    Gamma Real Estate wins the stalled supertall site at foreclosure auction

    Developer Bauhouse Group defaulted on a $147 million loan from Gamma Real Estate in January 2016. It then filed for bankruptcy two days before a scheduled foreclosure auction, which called the sale off. Gamma won the site at an auction that December and announced revised plans for a 67-story tower with 125 apartments.

    Source: Wikipedia

  5. 2017

    April 10

    Gamma closes on the $86 million site and hires Thomas Juul-Hansen as architect

    After winning the foreclosure auction, Gamma Real Estate closed on the $86 million purchase of the 3 Sutton Place site, according to 6sqft's April 10, 2017 report. Gamma also hired Thomas Juul-Hansen to design the tower, with Stephen B. Jacobs remaining as executive architect.

    Source: 6sqft

  6. 2018

    August

    The East River Fifties Alliance sues to stop construction of the 800-foot tower

    In a suit reported on August 30, 2018, the East River Fifties Alliance argued that the Board of Standards and Appeals improperly gave developer Gamma six extra months to finish its foundation and stay under the old zoning. It alleged the board did no independent review and asked a judge to halt construction. The group had earlier called the 800-foot tower a monstrous, out-of-place megatower.

    Source: habitatmag.com

  7. 2018

    June

    A neighborhood rezoning fight halts construction, then lets it resume

    Opposition to the supertall pushed the city to rezone the surrounding blocks, and the Council approved the rezoning in November 2017, with a 260-foot height limit for much of the area. Work stopped by the end of the year, when the foundation was nearly complete. Gamma Real Estate won approval from the Board of Standards and Appeals in June 2018, and construction resumed even as opponents kept trying to halt the project.

    Source: Wikipedia

  8. 2020

    August

    The 847-foot Sutton 58 tower tops out

    Thomas Juul-Hansen's stone-and-glass tower topped out in August 2020 at 847 feet, with a two-level penthouse at the crown. Its reinforced-concrete structure cantilevers about 10 feet over the neighboring building at 434 East 58th Street. The building was completed in 2022, after a project that began in 2015 as a roughly 1,000-foot design by Foster and Partners.

    Source: Wikipedia

  9. 2022

    The tower cantilevers about 10 feet over its neighbor at 434 East 58th Street

    Designed by Thomas Juul-Hansen and finished in 2022, the 847-foot tower has a stone-and-glass facade and a reinforced-concrete superstructure. It leans out slightly, extending about ten feet over the neighboring building at 434 East 58th Street. A two-level, five-bedroom penthouse sits at the top.

    “The tower is slightly cantilevered over a neighboring building to the east. The cantilever extends about 10 feet over the neighboring structure at 434 East 58th Street.”

    Source: Wikipedia

  10. 2024

    May 30

    Sutton Tower's completion is reported, with model units styled by three design teams

    6sqft reported on May 30, 2024 that the tower was complete and released a first look at its interiors. Model units were styled by three design teams: Vesta, Urban Casa and Eichholtz. The building holds 120 condominiums ranging from one to five bedrooms.

    Source: 6sqft

Further reading

Nearby

All 6 buildings with stories in Sutton Place